Short answer: if your locks are in good condition and you just need new keys, rekey them. If they are worn, damaged, low quality, or you want a new style or feature, replace them. Rekeying is usually the cheaper option.
Homeowners ask us this question every week, especially after buying a house. Here is how we explain it.
What rekeying actually does
Inside a pin-tumbler lock is a row of small pins of different lengths. Your key lifts them to exactly the right height so the cylinder can turn. When we rekey a lock, we take the cylinder apart and replace those pins with a new set matched to a new key. The lock body, the handle and the deadbolt stay the same. The old key no longer works.
A typical lock takes 10 to 20 minutes to rekey. A whole house is often done in under an hour.
When rekeying is the right choice
- You bought or moved into a home
- A key was lost or stolen
- A roommate, tenant, ex-partner or contractor had a key
- You want one key to open every exterior door (if the locks share a keyway)
- An employee left your business
When replacing makes more sense
- The lock is worn or damaged. Sticky cylinders, wobbly handles and bolts that will not extend fully are signs of wear.
- It is a low-quality lock. Bargain locks may not be worth rekeying, and they resist forced entry poorly.
- You want better security. A Grade 1 deadbolt, a high-security cylinder or a restricted keyway offers real protection against picking, bumping and unauthorized key copies.
- You want new features. Keypad and smart locks give you codes, phone access and auto-locking.
- You are renovating. New doors and finishes are the perfect time to upgrade hardware.
Cost comparison
Rekeying usually costs significantly less than replacing locks, because you pay for labour and pins, not new hardware. Replacing makes the most financial sense when a lock is failing anyway or you want an upgrade. Ask us for a quote for both and we will give you an honest recommendation.
Our rule of thumb: If the lock works smoothly and you like it, rekey it. If it fights you, or you want more security or features, replace it.
Can every lock be rekeyed?
Most common residential and commercial locks can be rekeyed, including many smart locks with key cylinders. Some very inexpensive locks are not designed to be serviced, and some high-security locks require authorized dealers. We can tell you in a minute when we see the lock.
Keyed alike: one key for every door
One of the most popular reasons to rekey is convenience. If your front door, back door and garage entry all use the same keyway, we can rekey them to work with a single key. If they do not, we can supply a matching cylinder or lock for the odd one out.
Rekeying for landlords and businesses
For landlords, rekeying between tenants is quicker and cheaper than replacing locks every time. Pair it with a restricted keyway so tenants cannot copy keys. For businesses, rekeying the affected doors when staff leave, or setting up a master key system, keeps control simple.
Signs a lock is wearing out
Not sure whether your lock is worth keeping? Look for these warning signs:
- The key is hard to insert or remove
- You have to jiggle the key or pull the door to lock it
- The handle or knob is loose and keeps loosening again
- The deadbolt does not fully extend, or only extends with force
- Visible rust, cracks or damage to the cylinder face
A lock that shows one of these signs may simply need cleaning, lubrication or an adjusted strike. Several signs together usually mean it is time to replace. In Regina, freeze-thaw cycles move door frames throughout the year, so strike adjustment is one of the most common fixes we make.
What about the patio door and garage?
Do not forget sliding patio doors, garage service doors and the door between an attached garage and the house. These are often keyed differently, or not keyed at all. When we rekey a home, we include every exterior entry so nothing is overlooked.
DIY rekeying kits
Some brands sell rekeying kits. They work for simple situations but require care, and a lost spring or pin can leave a lock unusable. If you want it done quickly and correctly, with every key tested, a locksmith is the safer bet.
Bottom line
For most Regina homeowners who just moved in, a full rekey plus one or two targeted upgrades, such as a better front deadbolt and reinforced strike plates, gives the best security for the money. Call (306) 525-5651 or book a rekey.